Input files – Opening ISPsim – Settings – Image processing blocks – Running – Sharpening –
Displays and analysis – Remosaicing – Optical Character Recognition (OCR) – Face and People Detection
The Imatest ISP (Image Signal Processing) Simulator module, ISPsim, simulates ISP pipelines, and with some limitations, complete camera systems. It evolved from the Imatest Image Processing module, but is much more powerful and flexible, allowing operations to be performed in arbitrary order. ISPsim can greatly speed up the development of image processing pipelines.
ISP input includes
- Bitmap test charts produced by the Imatest Test Charts module,
- Bitmap test chart files that have been processed by lens design programs, such as Code V,
- Raw (converted raw) images acquired from cameras. Highly processed images (most camera JPEGs) are not recommended.
ISPsim processing includes
- Camera and lens image degradations, such as noise, fog, and blur,
- Image adjustments, such as exposure (and gain), gamma, and Beyer demosaicing/mosaicing,
- image enhancements, such as applying a Color Correction Matrix, tone mapping (used in High Dynamic Range (HDR) imaging), Sharpening (standard or Unsharp Mask (USM)), and bilateral filtering,
- ability to simulate motion blur, low light conditions, and more.
ISPsim results
- can be immediately observed in the ISPsim interactive window. You can view input and output images individually or side-by-side, as well as the quantitative effects of processing, including SSIM, PSNR, MTF, Optical Character Recognition (OCR), and Face or People Detection,
- can be saved and exported to external programs, especially to Imatest, to obtain all major image quality metrics, including image information metrics.
ISPsim includes an accurate image sensor noise model, based on just two parameters (well capacity at maximum signal and dark noise). No radiometric calculations are needed, though they can be used to determine a camera’s absolute sensitivity.
ISPsim is expandable. Processing blocks will be added based on customer requests. The current set of blocks is primarily focused on operations that affect visible and measurable image quality.
ISPsim can operate on batches of images, automatically reading, processing and saving images in the batch.
ISPsim input files
ISP input can come from any image file, raw or demosaiced, that is readable by Imatest and listed in Image file formats and acquisition devices. There are three major sources of such files.
Test Charts program — The most convenient source of test chart images is the Imatest Test Charts program. Here is an example, illustrating settings for creating a 2400×1600 pixel Enhanced eSFR ISO 2017 chart.
Test Charts window for the Enhanced eSFR ISO 2017 chart
Although it is useful to read the documentation for Test Charts and SVG Test charts, we will try to provide enough information to get you started. You can also download the 2400×1600 PNG image (with added color patches) that we used for developing and testing ISPsim.
Test Charts lets you create SVG (Scalable Vector Graphics) or bitmap (TIFF or PNG) chart files that can be used for printing physical charts or for analyzing chart images. It contains a great many chart types, selectable in the Pattern dropdown menu. Chart patterns that have continuous tones (such as the sinusoidal Siemens Star) must be created as bitmap files, sized for printing or for Imatest analysis. SVG files can be opened by Inkscape (a beautiful free program) for printing in any size or conversion to PNG bitmap files (which can also be done within Test Charts). eSFR ISO charts, which are normally printed large, are created as SVG files, but you can save a bitmap (PNG) file by checking the Save PNG (bitmap) file box, just below the chart image, and selecting the desired image height in pixels.
Because bit depth for PNG images converted from SVG is limited to 8-bits (256 levels), we recommend keeping (display) Gamma = 2.2 (the inverse of the encoding gamma used in most common interchangeable files) to maximize the dynamic range. Some settings are hidden in dropdown menus. We recommend selecting eSFR LogWedge max = 4000 LW/PH in the Settings dropdown menu.
When your settings are complete, press Create Test Chart, and save the files (you’ll get both SVG and PNG) in a convenient location.
Lens design programs — such as Code V let you process chart images, degrading them (adding blur, chromatic aberration, vignetting) using a realistic lens model. The chart images can be created with the Imatest Target Generator, which is sort of a back-end for Test Charts, converting SVG charts to bitmap files. Charts for input to lens design programs must have gamma = 1 (linear gamma). The (blur) filter blocks won’t be needed.
Images acquired from cameras — Raw or minimally-processed images, converted to RGB with LibRaw or ReadRaw, work well. Most JPEG images from consumer cameras should be avoided because they are already heavily processed, including nonlinear and nonuniform bilateral filtering, making it difficult to obtain useful results. The (blur) filter and noise blocks won’t be needed.
Opening ISPsim
Press ISP Simulator in the the Utility dropdown menu or in the Utility tab on the right of the Imatest main window. This opens initial ISP Simulator window, which contains basic instructions and has many buttons grayed out (to minimize confusion). The instructions may be periodically updated. Before performing an analysis, an image file will need to be read in, and the settings (which are saved from the previous run) should be reviewed and updated if necessary. (The order of pressing Read image file and ISP Settings is irrelevant.)
ISP Simulation opening window. Click on image to view full-sized. The text will be updated.
To open the settings window, press the ISP Settings button on the upper-left of the ISP Simulator window. Since ISP settings are saved from the previous run, you don’t always need to open the settings window. Settings can be made before or after reading the image (but always before for batches of images).
The Settings window contains a large number of processing blocks. Some, like Sharpen or Bilateral Filter, have several associated parameters and are contained inside rectangular frames. Others, like Exposure or Gain, which have at most one associated parameter, are not displayed inside frames. Some closely related groups of processing blocks, like Bayer mosaic and Demosaic, and also inside frames. ISP settings screen
The Settings window contains a large number of processing blocks. Some, like Sharpen or Bilateral Filter, have several associated parameters and are contained inside rectangular frames. Others, like Exposure or Gain, which have at most one associated parameter, are not displayed inside frames.
The processing window, on the right, contains the sequence of operations. Blank lines are ignored. They are intended to make it easy to insert, arrange, and delete entries, and are removed when the settings are transferred to the main window.)
1. Choose a block to include in the image processing pipeline. |
2. Adjust parameters — sliders, popup menus, or edit boxes. |
3. Use the Set popup menu to enter the selected block into the Image Processing Blocks list box on the right. Note that all the Set popups contain the same contents: Set, 1, 2, 3, …, 20. Click on the Set popup, then click on the line number where you want the block to be entered. Choosing Set (instead of a line number) does nothing. |
4. The tint of the Set box indicates the status of the block. Green indicates that the block has been selected and appears in the Image Processing Blocks list box. Yellow indicates that the block has been adjusted, but not (yet) selected. Press Set, then Set (not a line number) to reset the box to white. |
5. The Image Processing Blocks list box contains many blank lines. They are there to make it easy to add and edit lines, and they are ignored when the calculations are performed. |
6. The order of the processing blocks can be conveniently edited using the buttons (Insert or Delete line, Move line up or down, etc.) below the Image Processing Blocks list box. |
7. Pressing OK saves the settings and closes the Settings window. The selected image processing blocks (with blank lines removed) appear in the ISP Simulator window. |
For example, Filter 1 (on the left of the settings window) was copied to line 3 by selecting the Set dropdown on the left of the Filter 1 frame, then selecting 3 in the dropdown menu (which contains 1-20). Most parameters are not copied to the Image Processing Blocks box; the parameters in the source block are used. Note that there is considerable space in the Settings window to add new blocks, and we are always interested in customer requests. Let us know.
Image processing blocks
As we indicated, updating the calculations (by pressing Update calculations, Step through calculations, or Step & show single block), applies image processing blocks in the selected sequence. Depending on the input image source, some of the enhancement steps may have been performed prior to entering the image into ISPsim. For example, JPEGs from consumer cameras typically have nonlinear, nonuniform bilateral filters (we don’t recommend them for ISPsim). Noise and filtering (blurring) have already been applied to images acquired from cameras.
Here is a list of the processing functions currently available (December 2024). Most are standard Matlab functions or custom Imatest code; the Lanman bilateral filteris a user-supplied function from the Mathworks File Exchange. Nonuniformity or nonlinearity are indicated in bold blue. Nonuniform or nonlinear operations are not recommended for image information metric calculations.
Processing block | Description | Function: described in link |
Input gamma |
Not actually a processing block, but critically important for keeping track of the image gamma at each state of the processing. There will almost certainly be errors if it is entered incorrectly. Typically 1 for (linear) raw images or around 0.45 or 0.5 for interchangeable color space images (sRGB, Adobe RGB, etc.) | |
Linearize | (equivalent to Gamma target 1, which is recommended) Linearize the image (remove the gamma encoding). Images can be linearized, operations can be applied, then gamma encoding can be reapplied to the final image, to be saved. Most useful with standard sharpening (the 2D version of the 1D sharpening described on the Sharpening page. Not for USM. As indicated, | |
Gamma | Add or remove gamma encoding from an image. There are cases where you may want to remove gamma encoding, apply filters, then reapply gamma encoding (in a second pass). The gamma value is relative to an assumed input gamma of 1. imageout = imageingamma | |
Negative | Invert the image, i.e., turn it into a negative (added in 5.0.4). | |
Image degradations: Often found in images acquired from cameras prior to processing. Operations are generally linear. | ||
Fog (flare) | Fog the image: equivalent to adding flare light or veiling glare. imageout = sqrt(fog + (1-fog)*handles.imagein2) |
|
Gaussian Filter 1 |
Blur the image (before applying noise). This simulates lens blurring. | imgaussfilt: 2-D Gaussian filtering of images with parameter sigma. |
Noise (Gaussian) | Add noise to the image. Will be filtered by Gaussian Filter 2. | imnoise: Add noise to the HSV V channel. Parameters sigma [] and Luma noise []. |
Gaussian Filter 2 | Blur the image + noise (after applying noise). This affects the noise spectrum. The spectrum for σ = 0.5 is similar to output of demosaicing (in raw conversion), which decreases noise from 1 to 0.5 at Nyquist. | imgaussfilt: 2-D Gaussian filtering of images with parameter sigma. |
Tonal enhancement: Correct colors or apply one of three tone mapping algorithms, used for displaying High Dynamic Range (HDR) images. Tonal response may be highly nonlinear. | ||
Color Correction Matrix (CCM) | Apply a Color Correction Matrix (CCM), which can be calculated and saved in Multicharts. Saved values are entered when Image Processing is opened. The Set CCM button to the right of the CCM checkbox opens a window (shown on the right; click on thumbnail to view full-sized) that lets you set up the matrix (read it from a file or paste it from the clipboard and select options (linearization, etc.)). | Color Correction Matrix describes the CCM, which is calculated in Multicharts. |
Tone mapping | Render high dynamic range (HDR) image for viewing: convert a high dynamic range image to a lower dynamic range image, suitable for display, using a process called tone mapping. Tone mapping is a technique used to approximate the appearance of high dynamic range images on a display with a more limited dynamic range. Nonuniform and nonlinear | tonemap: Render high dynamic range image for viewing |
Local tone mapping | Alternative tone mapping algorithm for HDR images using Laplacian filtering. Has a different set of adjustments. Produces different results (more saturated images). Nonuniform and nonlinear | localtonemap |
Contrast-Limited Histogram Equalization | CLAHE operates on small regions in the image, called tiles, rather than the entire image. Each tile’s contrast is enhanced, so that the histogram of the output region approximately matches the histogram specified by the ‘Distribution’ parameter. The neighboring tiles are then combined using bilinear interpolation to eliminate artificially induced boundaries. The contrast, especially in homogeneous areas, can be limited to avoid amplifying any noise that might be present in the image. Nonuniform and nonlinear | adapthisteq: Contrast-limited adaptive histogram equalization (CLAHE) |
Spatial enhancement: sharpening and/or noise reduction. Output depends on image content— may be highly nonlinear. | ||
Sharpen USM (Unsharp Mask) |
Sharpens the grayscale or RGB input image using the unsharp masking (USM) method. Most visible on edges. USM works by subtracting a gaussian blur function from the original image. If threshold > 0, low-contrast regions may not be sharpened. See Wikipedia. This function is not linear. It caused some inconsistencies with the image information metrics. Designed to work directly on images, which should not be linearized. Nonlinear (a surprise; not indicated in MATLAB documentation) |
imsharpen: Unsharp Masking (USM) |
Sharpen (New in |
Sharpens the grayscale or RGB input image using a 2D version of the 1D sharpening method described in the Sharpening page. Most visible on edges. It works by subtracting an amplitude-reduced replica of the original image, arranged on a circular locus with radius R, from the original image. To maintain linearity, Linearize should be checked. This causes the image to be linearized (gamma-encoding removed) at the start of the calculations. Then sharpening is applied to the linearized image, then gamma encoding is reapplied. Recommended for testing the effects of sharpening on image information metrics, such as SNRi or Edge SNRi. Because standard sharpening is not a MATLAB function, we include more explanation in the box below. |
Custom function. Either USM or Standard sharpen can be applied (but not both). |
Bilateral filter |
Nonuniform |
bfilter2 (from the Mathworks File Exchange): |
A complete (though elementary) Image Processing pipeline can be simulated by reading a raw or minimally processed image (demosaiced by ReadRaw), then applying operations such as Color Correction Matrix (which also applies a gamma curve), sharpening, and a bilateral filter (a simple example— there are many options).
Sharpening (standard; not USM) is an Imatest (not a MATLAB) function, designed to maintain linearity. As we mentioned above, this is a 2D version of the 1D sharpening method described in the Sharpening page. It was created when we were trying to determine if USM, which is implemented with the MATLAB imfilter function, is nonlinear (it is). It is also closer to typical camera sharpening than USM, which is more computationally intensive. For sharpening radius R and amount A, define ksharp = A/(A+1). The filter kernel is a 2R+1×2R+1 matrix H (units of pixels), calculated by (1) setting each entry at a distance r from the center to H(r) = max(|R-r|,0), (2) setting H = H/∑H, then setting the entry at the center, H(R+1,R+1) = 1. For a filter with Radius = 2, Amount = 3 (strongly sharpened), the 5×5 kernel is -0.0092 -0.0409 -0.0535 -0.0409 -0.0092 Standard sharping should be used with Linearize γ for gamma-encoded images. It is a linear operation (as long as excessive sharpening doesn’t saturate the image). |
Running ISPsim
Read an input image file if it hasn’t been read in already. The sequence of reading an image file and updating the settings doesn’t matter. Most types of image can be used, though as we indicated above, we don’t recommend highly processed JPEGs from consumer cameras. It doesn’t have to be a test chart. You can crop the image for analysis now or later— the crop setting will be maintained.
Here is the Image Processing display for an image of a Spilled Coins chart (cropped). The input image (of good quality, but with some visible noise) is displayed.
Image processing window showing Spilled Coins input image
Zoomed in (for display-only)
Cropping and zooming— There are two distinct types of crop/zoom operation: zooming for display-only and cropping for calculations (as well as display).
- Zooming (cropping for display-only) is performed by the standard Matlab procedures: clicking on the image (to zoom in), dragging and clicking to select a region, or by double-clicking (to zoom out). These does not affect calculations such as MTF.
- Cropping for calculations as well as display is performed by pressing the Crop button in the Analysis and View area below the image. This brings up the standard Imatest coarse and fine crop windows. This approach affects calculations such as the MTF curve (which is image-dependent for several processing blocks) or the mean SSIM calculation (though the detailed SSIM plot is unaffected). Pressing the Crop button enables the Zoom out and Zoom to crop buttons on the lower-right of the window. To remove the crop, press the Crop button and select the entire image.
Utilities
Several utilities are available in the dropdown menus at the top of the image processing window. (There is little room for added buttons in the window.)
File | Display and/or Save screen | Display the screen in an image viewer (Irfanview recommended) and optionally save it. This function is in several interactive modules. |
Save image | Save the processed image. Normally images will be saved in full precision (except if 8-bit max (below) is checked). | |
Save pseudo-raw/remosaiced image | Save the image in a pseudo-raw (remosaiced) or special format, including Bayer, RCCC, or specific channel can be selected. Many options. See Synthetic RAW images. | |
Save image as monochrome | Save the image (which may be color) as a monochrome image. | |
Swap Endian (16, 32-bit input) | Swap the order of bytes within pixels (useful in rare instances where they are incorrect) | |
Save image files with 8-bit max precision | Unchecked (off) by default. If set, images will be saved in 8-bit precision. (This should normally be unchecked). | |
Save image as HDR | Save the image in HDR (High Dynamic Range) format | |
View | Colorbar (grayscale or color) | Grayscale or color: Used in SSIM and PSNR displays. The colors in the color bar can be changed in Options II. |
Crop | Lets you select a crop for image analysis operations (MTF, SSIM, etc.) Same as the Crop button in the Analysis and View area. | |
Analysis | Most functions duplicate buttons in the Analysis and View section, but there are several additions. | |
Image Statistics | Call the Image Statistics module for viewing image statistics such as histograms and cross-section profiles. | |
Radial Geometry | Call the Radial Geometry module, which can return an image with added or corrected optical distortion, lateral chromatic aberration, and/or rotation. | |
OCR | Optical Character Recognition using Matlab’s OCR function | |
Detect faces | Uses the Matlab CAMShift routine, described below. | |
Detect people | Uses the Matlab detectPeopleACF routine, described below. Less effective than Face detection. | |
Help | Open web pages with descriptions of various image processing blocks. |
Results display and analysis
The display is controlled by buttons below the image or by the Analysis dropdown menu. You can choose between a visual display of the Input or Processed image or a calculated display (an analysis comparing the input and processed images).
Input | Display the input image (1) |
Processed | Display the processed image (2) |
MTF | Display the MTF of the processed / input image as a function of spatial frequency. Sensitive to cropping. |
MTFnn | Display a polar plot of MTF70-MTF10 (spatial frequencies where MTF is nn% of low frequency value) |
MTFnnP | Display a polar plot of MTF70P-MTF10P (spatial frequencies where MTF is nn% of peak value) |
SSIM | Display the Structural Similarity Index, which is discussed in detail on the page for the SSIM module. Better correlated to visual differences (degradations) than PSNR. |
PSNR & DIff | Display the Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio and the difference between images. |
OCR | Optical Character Recognition results using Matlab’s OCR function |
Detect faces | Face detection results using the Matlab CAMShift routine. |
Detect people | People detection results using the Matlab detectPeopleACF routine, described below. Less effective than Face detection. |
The View input button on the left, just below the image, toggles between View input (when the processed image is selected) and View processed (when the input image is selected). This enables rapid visual comparison of the two images. The zoom setting is preserved when you switch images. The View input/processed button performs the same functions as the Input and Processed buttons in the Analysis and View area. The other buttons in this area display calculated results.
SSIM displays the Structural Similarity Index, which is discussed in detail on the page for the SSIM module. It’s primary use is in measuring the visible effects (i.e., degradation) of image compression from saving files (for example, JPEGs of varying quality) and from data transmission.
MTF (Modulation Transfer Function) calculates the transfer function between the Processed and Input images using a 2D Fourier transform similar to the calculation in the Random module, but with one important difference. Unlike the Random module, where the scaled Power Spectral Density in gray areas to the left and right of the active area (the random/Spilled Coins/Dead Leaves pattern) is subtracted from the total power spectral density of the active area to remove most of the noise, there is no noise reduction. Hence this MTF measurement is extremely sensitive to noise.
MTF for noisy Gaussian-filtered image after Unsharp Masking
The high frequency rolloff is the effect of Gaussian filter 2, which is applied after the noise has been added (and hence shapes the spectral power of the noise). You can see the MTF for Unsharp Mask (USM)-only (in this case with Radius = 1.5 and Amount = 2.5) by unchecking Noise (gaussian) and Gaussian filter 2 in the Image Processing area to the left of the image, then pressing Update calculations. Unsharp Masking has a different spectral response from the type of sharpening described in the Sharpening page: It’s response is not cyclical. It rises to an asymptotic level of Amount+1 and stays high. This is a good example of how Image Processing can be used to explore the effects of processing blocks on both appearance and measurements. |
MTF for USM (Unsharp Mask: Radius = 1.5; Amount = 2.5) |
Side-by-side view
The side-by-side view allows you to compare the input and processed images side-by-side, i.e., right next to each other. Click the Side-by-side view checkbox just below View input or View processed (on the left, below the image). When the box is first checked the two images are displayed in their entirety. If you crop one, the other will have the identical crop. This makes for meaningful comparisons.
Side-by-side view of Dead Leaves chart. Noise, Bilateral filter, and USM added on the right.
When Side-by-side view is enabled, the Analysis and view section on the bottom (which contains MTF, SSIM, etc.) is disabled. Uncheck to re-enable it.
Remosaicing (undemosaicing)
By clicking File, Save pseudo-raw (undemosaiced) image (after a file has been read), you can save the image in a synthetic Bayer RAW format as well as one of several other formats. The output can be a standard image file format or pure binary. A dialog box opens that allows a number of options.
Mosaicing or channel selection None (Normal color file output), Remosaic (Bayer format), RCCC (Red-Clear-Clear-Clear): R bright, RCCC (Red-Clear-Clear-Clear): R = C/3, Monochrome (Y = luminance), Monochrome (mean: equal weights), Red, Green, Blue. For remosaicing (creating Bayer RAW files), Remosaic (Bayer format) would be selected.
Red in RmCn lets you select one of the four Bayer configurations.
Gamma adjust lets you adjust the gamma of the output curve. Keep it at 1 for no change. Use 2 (or 2.2) to go from a typical color space gamma to linear (gamma = 1).
Save file format lets you select a standard image file format (PNG, JPG (90% quality), TIF (large), BMP, Binary 8-bit, or Binary 16-bit. The binary files can be read into Generalized Read Raw.
Green channel emphasis lets you emphasize the green channel so that the synthetic RAW image resembles actual raw images, which typically are strongest in green. Several Blue/Red levels are available.
When you select Save, a dialog box lets you select the location and file name. The default is root_file_name_png (with the selected extension).
Optical Character Recognition (OCR)
OCR has been added in Imatest 5.0, using Matlab’s OCR function, which is an implementation of Tesseract-OCR. To use it,
This opens the OCR window and performs a text recognition operation on the crop of the image. Results for the sample image on the right (mildly degraded with Noise (gaussian) = 0.002; Gaussian filter 2 = 0.7) are shown below. You can download this image and experiment with to see how various degradations and enhancements affect OCR performance. Be forewarned. Matlab’s OCR performance is not impressive. Text that appears to be quite readable does not do well, especially for font sizes under 12 points. Performance is comparable to several free or low-cost OCR programs such as gImageReader (a GUI front-end for Tesseract-ocr) and TopOCR. |
Sample image: Click for a The left side sample image consists a set of characters (QWERTYUIOPASDFGHJKLZXCVBNM1234567890) of different sizes ranging from 20 to 7 points in normal, bold, and negative bold Calibri font. These are characters used in automotive license plates. The file (here) was created in Microsoft Word. The remainder of the image is a portion of the Enhanced eSFR ISO chart, with wedges and two high contrast squares. These can be used to correlate MTF measurements with OCR performance. |
OCR window, showing results for mildly-degraded crop of the sample image
OCR Settings
Character Subset Results can be improved by entering a character subset to limit the valid output characters (all characters are allowed if Character Subset is blank), then pressing CALCULATE OCR. For the sample image, the subset consists of Latin capital letters and numbers (typical of automobile license places). It makes only a small improvement.
QWERTYUIOPASDFGHJKLZXCVBNM1234567890
Standard OCR does not work very well with license plates. Several license plate detection routines are available in the Matlab File Exchange. We may add one or two if they work well and the license allows.
Display Text (shown) is the default. You can also select Confidence & words, which shows the Word Confidence and individual word. Here are a few lines from the display.
0.8545 QWERTYUIOPASDFGHJKLZXCVBNM1234567890
0.8361 QWERTYUIOPASDFGHJKLZXCVBNM123456789O
0.9018 18
0.7842 QWERTVU|OPASDF6HJKLZX(VBNM1234567890
0.8339 16
0.7468 QWEKTYUIOPASDFGHJKLZXCVBNM1234567B90
0.8254 14
0.7252 QWERYYUIOPASDFGI-1JKLZX(\/ENM1Z34567E9(!
0.7784 12
0.5777 QWERTYUWDDASDFGHJI(LZXCVBNM113A567E9u
0.6549 11
0.6276 uwEuHu\onAsur:.r<n<.zxn’aNM:23-4ss7s9u
0.7658 m
Copy to clipboard You can copy the current display into the clipboard for use in text editors or other applications.
Save results saves the current display.
Variable or fixed width font can be selected in the Settings dropdown menu.
Face and People detection
Face and people detection can be called from the Analysis dropdown menu. Both currently use the Matlab default settings. (We may add an options window in the future.) See
Face Detection and Tracking Using CAMShift and detectPeopleACF
Face detection works somewhat better than people detection. Here is an example, using an image shamelessly stolen from http://epaperpress.com/portfolio/columbia.html. The soggy author of Imatest is on the left. Click Update Calculations to remove the annotations (to reset the image).
Example of Face Detection (Imatest author on the left)
Face detection works pretty well much of the time, but seriously… How can you miss Paul and John?